I am an electrical engineering student at the University of the Philippines Los Baños.
A Comparison Between Nickel-Metal Hydride (NiMH) and Lithium-ion (Li-ion) Batteries
Modern society is powered by various electronic devices such as cell phones, laptops, and cameras. All of these things use batteries. There are many types out there and each type has their strengths and weaknesses. For this article, we will discuss and compare NiMH and Li-ion batteries.
These types of batteries are usually used for high drain devices like laptops, cellphones, iPods, and digital cameras. However, they have some distinguishing features which make one type more efficient in than the other in some regards.
- High Energy Density: These have an average of 2200mAh (milliampere hours—the amount of current in milliamperes that it can give multiplied by the time in hours.) This is greater than the 1500mAh seen in Li-ion batteries. These are the standard numbers in 1.2v NiMHs and 3.7v Li-ions.
- Compatibility: If you have ten gadgets using an NiMH battery, you can use a single pack to power them all. Not simultaneously of course. NiMH uses standard sizes so they are compatible with all devices using sizes such as AAA or AA. Compared to Li-ions, the sizes depend on the manufacturer or model of the device. I did see some AA size Li-ions around the market so it may be worth checking them out.
- They Are Safer: They have less active materials compared to Li-ion batteries. NiMH can pop if they are overcharged too much or short circuit but this is nothing compared to a Li-ion which can potentially blow up.
- Can Be Completely Discharged: By this I mean they can be brought down to 0 charge, if you can get it to reach that. They will still charge, just don't let it suffer from reverse polarity or else they will be damaged.
- High Self Discharge Rate: NiMH lose a large percentage of their charge every month. The number is around 5% on the first week after the charge and about 50% on the first month. There are low-self discharge (LSD) rate types available. They are more reliable than the standard NiMH but they have lower capacities, usually around 2000mAh.
- Unreliable for Low Load Devices: You should not use NiMH batteries for devices such as clocks. They will lose charge faster through self-discharge rather than the load. Use alkaline, Li-ion, or lithium batteries instead.
- Low Voltage Output: Each AA cell can only give 1.2v compared to Li-ion cells which can give 3.7v.
- Long Charging Time: The standard charge time of a NiMH is 10-12 hours. Fast charging these cells can result in damage. Li-ion cells can be charged at around 1-3 hours depending on capacity.
- Cannot Operate at Extreme Temperature: At extreme temperatures, NiMH voltage output will drop. Li-ion batteries can tolerate these temperatures to some extent.
- Reliable: These have a significantly lower self-discharge rate than a NiMH battery. As a result, they can be used for low-current devices like clocks or watches watches.
- Small: They are smaller and lighter compared to NiMH batteries.
- Higher Voltage Output: A single cell can deliver 3.7v while even two NiMH cells can only give 2.4v.
- Faster Recharge: Li-ions can be charged in about 1-3 hours, depending on capacity. This is much faster than the 10-12 hours needed for NiMH batteries.
- Temperature Tolerance: These can better stand low temperature and warmer environments compared to NiMH cells.
- Higher Energy Density: This means that the battery carries more charge per gram than a NiMH battery.
- Lower Capacity: These have an average of 1500mAh compared to the 2200 mAH average of NiMH cells.
- Incompatibility: Different manufacturers make different sizes and shapes for Li-ion batteries, making them usable only to a specific set of devices. NiMHs have standard sizes.
- Have Active Materials Like Lithium Batteries: Ions are a very active material. They can react easily and generate a lot of heat. That’s why there are circuits in those cells. They are used to check for voltage and temperature. In other words, the circuits prevents the cells from blowing up.
- Cannot Be Completely Discharged: If a Li-ion battery gets fully discharged, it will be damaged. Yes, you can shock charge it but its efficiency will decrease. Always keep this kind of battery charged above 50%.
This article is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge. Content is for informational or entertainment purposes only and does not substitute for personal counsel or professional advice in business, financial, legal, or technical matters.
Nikola Tesla on August 24, 2020:
I go defenitely with nimh!
Eibdelov on February 27, 2020:
Latest nimh batteries are capable of high speed charging as am using in latest fast charging trimmers of philips
Renta Dick Fukyosnatch on January 23, 2020:
This article is so poorly written I already don't trust your factual claims on the topic at all, let alone this specific issue. I'm not saying you're wrong, but this entire piece was so poorly written, i might as well not have even read what you had to say about it.
Mostofa Kamal Ahmed on March 25, 2019:
NiMH is better than Li-ion
Matthew on March 07, 2019:
So much wrong with this article that I don't know where to start.
Well, to begin with - energy density is current x time x voltage. You are missing the voltage part. Li-ion batteries actually have much higher energy density.
If you said "higher charge density" you would be right, but no one actually cares about that. It's energy density that's important.
Ecospider5 on December 16, 2018:
Low self discharge NIMH are way better than you state. They hold over 80% charge for 3+ years.
Raffles on November 23, 2018:
@Enricoludo to power your 12V 2.6A fan for up to 8 hours, you need a at least a 21Ah 12V battery, however that would run it completely flat, so you probably want to get something a bit bigger than a 21Ah battery. Really you are looking at a lead acid leisure battery for this, rather than either NiMh or LI-ion. If you do want to use NiMh batteries you will need to put 10 in series to get to 12V. A standard NiMh AA battery is typically around 2 Ah capacity, so you will need around 12 in parallel, to get 24 Ah capacity. 12 x 10 = 120 NiMh AA batteries to power your 12V 2.6A fan for 8 hours. That will cost a lot more than a standard 12V leisure battery, and when they are flat, you will have 120 NiMh AA batteries to recharge before you can use the fan again. Alternatively looking at Li-ion batteries, put 3 in series to get 11.1V which is close enough to 12V to power a fan. A standard Li-ion 18650 battery is typically 2.5Ah capacity so you will need 10 in parallel to get 25 Ah. 10 x 3 = 30 Li-ion 18650 batteries. Not as bad for recharging as the AA batteries, but still a big job. I have a third suggestion. Get a solar panel. I assume you only want the fan running when it is hot and sunny, which is perfect for gaining solar power. The batteries then only need to have enough capacity for when the light fades and the panel isn't giving you enough power to run the fan by itself. Your fan draws 31 W of power. You need a solar panel that is rated at least double that power as solar panels rarely produce the power they're rated at (only when the sun light is hitting them at exactly 90°). So I would recommend you get say a 75W solar panel and a small 12V leisure battery (say 7Ah). I've got a set up like this in my home, although I use it for phone charging rather than powering a fan. I hope this helps.
Tom Jones on March 01, 2018:
Nonsense about ions in lithium batteries and circuits preventing blowing up. Utter rubbish. The circuits protect the batteries from discharging too low and preventing reverse charge. All batteries have a potential to blow up if they are fully charged and a short occurs, even ones with the protection circuits.
Really this article should be completely removed. It is riddled with all sorts of misinformation.
Darren Perkins on April 27, 2017:
Doesn't look like the article was updated at all...now I don't know what to believe. Just delete the article for the sake of not confusing people who want to know the facts. Article is completely useless.
Enricoludo on April 18, 2017:
Hi, I want to power a 12v 2.6A fan when camping, I would like to keep running it for 6-8 hrs. Minimum, what options do you suggest is best for this purpose. Thank you for your expertise!
smolny on March 23, 2016:
Others claim that Ni-MH are more tolerant to charge/discharge at lower/higher temperatures than Li-Ion (and esp. Li-Poly). Would you be so kind and double-check your sources about it?
John R Wilsdon from Superior, Arizona USA on February 06, 2016:
As a person frustrated in the past with how to make a decision about batteries, this hub was very helpful and well designed. I will refer to it in the future before a purchase. Thank you.
leakeem (author) from Earth on May 04, 2015:
Sirs, article has been updated.
Radmila on December 12, 2014:
Well put, sir, well put. I'll cerltinay make note of that.
Trevor on July 10, 2014:
10 months have gone by since this very significant comment that I almost didn't read. Can you update this article for the sake of correct information?
leakeem (author) from Earth on September 12, 2013:
Thanks for the update/info! Will update that soon.
Michael Cline on September 12, 2013:
Be advised the energy density is actually much higher for Li-ion versus NiMH. Energy density is measured in Watt Hours/weight, not mAh/weight. Also, NiMH can be recharged much faster than Li-ion currently. You can list an additional Con for NiMH that it requires a much more complex charging algorithm. You can remove the self-discharge Con form NiMH since the new type cells do not have this problem anymore.